Last updated: November 2026
The Convenience of the Employer Rule
What the rule actually does
The convenience rule departs from sourcing wages to where the work is physically performed. Under it, a day a nonresident employee spends working from home counts as a day worked in the employer’s state. That holds unless the employee worked from home because the employer required it, rather than because the employee preferred it.
The distinction is necessity versus convenience.
| Why the employee worked elsewhere | Where the day is sourced |
|---|---|
| Necessity: the job could not be done at the employer’s location | Where the work happened |
| Convenience: the employee could have come to the office and chose not to | The office state |
For payroll, that means physical presence is not the withholding input under the rule. Counting badge swipes or calendar days produces the wrong number.
What counts as the employer’s location
Every convenience rule turns on the employer’s state, and that phrase carries more weight than it looks. It is not a fact about the company. It is a fact about each individual employee.
Three things it is not. It is not the headquarters address. It is not where payroll is processed or where the payroll provider sits. It is not where the employee’s supervisor happens to live.
What it is: the employee’s assigned or primary work location. New Jersey’s Division of Taxation describes it as generally the office out of which the employee is supervised. New York’s guidance uses the parallel concept, an assigned or primary work location that is an established office of the employer inside the state. The determination is made employee by employee, which means one company can have some employees inside a convenience rule and some outside it.
Multiple offices
Where an employer has offices in several states, each employee’s primary or assigned office controls. A company with offices in a convenience rule state and a non-convenience rule state has two answers, not one.
Offices that have closed
Closing an office does not resolve prior years, and it may not resolve the current one. In the Zelinsky litigation, New York taxed remote work days in 2019 and 2020, including 2020 days when a state executive order barred the employee from the New York office. The Tax Appeals Tribunal determined that the employer did not require the employee to work in Connecticut, only off campus. The court held that determination rational and supported by substantial evidence.
Employees with no assigned office
An employee hired to work remotely who has never been assigned to an office is the clearest case for the rule not applying. There is no established office in the state serving as their work location. It is also the position that rests on documentation, because the assignment itself is what has to be established. It is defended with the offer letter, the job posting, the organization chart, and the human resources system’s work location field, not with an argument made after the fact.
Which states apply it
New York, Delaware, Connecticut, New Jersey and Pennsylvania each source a nonresident’s out-of-state work days to the employer’s state when the work was done for the employee’s convenience. They divide into three groups.
Applied to any nonresident: New York, Delaware
New York’s rule sits in its tax regulations at 20 NYCRR 132.18(a), in the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR). The Court of Appeals upheld it against constitutional challenge in 2003 and again in 2005. The Appellate Division, Third Department, rejected a further challenge on July 2, 2026 in Matter of Zelinsky v Commissioner of Taxation and Finance.
Delaware applies a long-standing administrative position.
Applied only against residents of other convenience rule states: Connecticut and New Jersey
Connecticut’s rule engages only when the nonresident employee’s state of domicile uses a similar test, and it applies for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2019.
New Jersey enacted its version in 2023, effective for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2023. The Division of Taxation is direct about the mechanism: New Jersey does not have a convenience rule of its own. It applies the rule of the employee’s home state. A telecommuting New York resident working for a New Jersey employer is measured against New York’s test, not a New Jersey one.
New Jersey identifies Delaware, Nebraska, and New York as states that trigger it, and excludes Pennsylvania residents because of the reciprocal agreement between the two states. The rule also reaches work done from a third state, so a New York resident working from a vacation home elsewhere is still sourced to New Jersey.
Applied to any nonresident under a stated doctrine: Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania follows the convenience of the employer doctrine, in the words of the Department of Revenue’s Personal Income Tax Guide. Compensation for services performed by nonresidents cannot be allocated to the actual place of performance if the services were performed there only for the employee’s convenience. The same holds if they were not performed there of necessity in the service of the employer.
The guide names two factors and no others. The first is whether the services performed outside the taxing jurisdiction were performed in the service, and for the benefit, of the employer. The second is whether they could have been performed at an office of the employer within the taxing jurisdiction. That includes an office where the employer could have made suitable accommodations available.
The Department’s telework guidance covers the necessity side. A nonresident required to telework full time from home in another state should treat that compensation as non-Pennsylvania source income, even when the employer is in Pennsylvania. In that situation, the employer is not required to withhold.
Convenience language with a seven-day threshold: Nebraska
Nebraska’s statute uses convenience language, but it taxes a nonresident only on pay for days worked in Nebraska, and only after more than seven days there in the year. Take a nonresident employee who is paid convenience rule wages and works seven employment duty days or less while present in Nebraska during a calendar year. For tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, none of that employee’s wages are subject to Nebraska income tax withholding. Once that employee exceeds seven employment duty days, all days worked in Nebraska are subject to Nebraska income tax withholding. The Nebraska employer then withholds only on wages for the work performed while present in Nebraska, so physical presence sets the withholding there.
Sourcing by physical presence: Alabama, Arkansas and Oregon
| State | The rule | Also in the rule |
|---|---|---|
| Alabama | The Department of Revenue notice posted August 25, 2026, limits withholding to the part of a nonresident’s wages attributable to services physically performed in Alabama. | A 30-day safe harbor exempts certain out-of-state workers performing services in Alabama for 30 or fewer days in a calendar year. |
| Arkansas | Under Act 1019 of 2021, nonresidents pay tax only on the income earned while physically present in Arkansas when performing the work. | Act 1019 also amends the definition of employer under the Arkansas Income Tax Withholding Act of 1965. |
| Oregon | Under Oregon Administrative Rule (OAR) 150-316-0165(3)(a), income is allocable to Oregon to the extent the employee is physically present in Oregon when the service is performed. | Subsection (3)(b) covers corporate officers and executives who spend only a portion of their time in Oregon. If a corporation operating in Oregon pays them exclusively for managerial services, their entire compensation is taxable. |
In Alabama, withholding is not required solely because the employer is located there when the employee performs no services in the state. Alabama’s Department of Revenue will not follow a March 8, 2023 Tax Tribunal ruling to the extent it is inconsistent with the notice. The ruling is Bollinger v. State of Alabama Department of Revenue.
The Alabama regulation on gross income of nonresidents applies the test of physical presence. The exception is where the peculiar nature of the services causes the objective of the employment to be accomplished or to take effect within the state.
Arkansas’s amended definition of employer includes a person doing business in or deriving income from sources outside the state who controls the payment of wages for services performed in Arkansas.
Oregon’s rule determines presence by the actual physical location of the employee, not by the location of the employer. Subsection (1)(b) excludes compensation for services performed wholly outside Oregon and in no way connected with the management or conduct of a business in Oregon. That holds even where payment is made from a point within the state or the employer is a resident.
OAR 150-316-0255 requires withholding on all wages paid to nonresidents for services performed in Oregon. Where a nonresident earns wages both in and outside Oregon, only the part earned in Oregon is subject to withholding.
Massachusetts: a temporary pandemic rule with a stated end condition
Massachusetts adopted a temporary pandemic sourcing rule at 830 CMR 62.5A.3, in the Code of Massachusetts Regulations (CMR). It covers a nonresident who was performing services in Massachusetts immediately before the state of emergency and then performed them from outside the state due to a pandemic-related circumstance. That compensation is treated as Massachusetts source income. The rule applies to services performed from March 10, 2020 through 90 days after the Governor gives notice that the Massachusetts COVID-19 state of emergency is no longer in effect. The regulation states that end condition and carries no notice that it has been met.
Confirm any state’s current position with that state’s department of revenue before configuring withholding.
New York published a factor test
The New York Tax Department’s technical memorandum TSB-M-06(5)I, issued May 15, 2006, enumerates a primary factor, six secondary factors and ten other factors. It sets out when a home office qualifies as a bona fide employer office. If it qualifies, normal work days spent there are treated as days worked outside New York. The memo applies to tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2006. For part-year residents it applies only to the nonresident portion of the year.
One threshold question comes before all of it. The test engages only when the employee’s assigned or primary work location is an established office of the employer in New York State. If the employee’s primary work location is a bona fide employer office outside New York, home days are already out-of-state days and the test never runs.
The primary factor
The home office contains or is near specialized facilities that cannot be made available at the employer’s place of business. The memo’s own example is a test track for evaluating vehicles. Equipment that could physically be installed at the employer’s New York location does not meet this factor, even if it currently sits at the employee’s home.
The six secondary factors
| Factor | What the memo asks | Who controls it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The home office is a requirement or condition of employment. | The employer |
| 2 | The employer has a bona fide business purpose for a location where the employee’s home is. | The employer |
| 3 | The employee performs some core duties of the job at the home office. | Turns on what the employee does |
| 4 | The employee meets clients, patients, or customers there on a regular and continuous basis. | Turns on what the employee does |
| 5 | The employer provides no designated office space or other regular work accommodation at one of its regular places of business. | The employer |
| 6 | The employer reimburses substantially all home office expenses, defined in the memo as 80 percent or more. Alternatively, it pays fair rental value for the space and furnishes or reimburses substantially all supplies and equipment. | The employer |
The ten other factors
- Separate business telephone line and listing.
- Home office address and phone on the employer’s letterhead or business cards.
- A specific area used exclusively for the employer’s business and separate from the living area, which fails if the space is used for both business and personal purposes.
- Inventory or product samples kept there when the employer sells at wholesale or retail.
- Employer business records stored there.
- Signage indicating a place of business.
- Employer advertising showing the home office as a place of business.
- Business insurance policy or a business rider on the homeowner policy.
- The employee is entitled to and actually claims a federal home office deduction.
- The employee is not an officer of the company.
The threshold, and the one factor most employees can no longer meet
A home office qualifies if it meets either the primary factor, or at least four of the six secondary factors and at least three of the other factors.
That is an either-or, not a cumulative score. Meeting the primary factor alone is sufficient. Meeting three secondary factors and nine others is not.
The other factor list has a problem the 2006 memo could not anticipate. It asks whether the employee claims a federal home office deduction. Under section 67(h) of the Internal Revenue Code, no miscellaneous itemized deduction is allowed for any taxable year beginning after December 31, 2017. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act added that suspension as subsection (g) with an end date of January 1, 2026. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act struck the end date and redesignated the subsection as (h), effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025.
An employee home office deduction is a miscellaneous itemized deduction. Section 67(b) lists the itemized deductions that are not, and the section 162 deductions on that list are educator expenses and impairment-related work expenses. Most W-2 employees cannot satisfy that factor.
The threshold is still at least three of the other factors.
The accountable plan route is what remains. Amounts an employer pays to reimburse home office expenses under an accountable plan are not wages. They are not subject to income, social security, Medicare or federal unemployment (FUTA) taxes. The employee must substantiate the expenses within a reasonable period of time and return any amount in excess of what was substantiated. The same reimbursement feeds secondary factor six.
Qualifying changes the allocation, not the liability
A qualifying home office does not exempt anyone from New York tax. It changes which days count.
Days actually worked in New York remain New York source income. What qualification changes is the treatment of normal work days spent at the home office, which move from the New York column to the outside New York column. A day at the home office that is not a normal work day is a nonworking day and does not enter the calculation on either side. Responding to occasional calls or email, reading professional material, or being available if needed does not make a day a normal work day.
Where payroll actually gets this wrong
The employer does not make this determination. The employee does, on Form IT-2104.1, the New York State, City of New York, and City of Yonkers Certificate of Nonresidence and Allocation of Withholding Tax.
Part 1 asks the employee to certify nonresidence and to estimate the percentage of services performed within New York State.
The form’s instructions say the percentage may be figured on days, miles, time, or similar criteria. They offer one example: an employee working in New York two days out of five performs 40 percent of services in New York.
The instructions never mention the convenience of the employer rule.
So consider an employee who lives outside New York, is assigned to the employer’s New York office, and works three days a week from home. The home office does not qualify as a bona fide employer office.
| Method | New York days in a five-day week | Percentage on the certificate |
|---|---|---|
| Following the instruction on the form | 2 | 40 percent |
| Under the convenience rule | 5, because non-qualifying home office days are New York work days | 100 percent, the correct figure |
Two documents from the same department, neither referencing the other, and the one the employee actually fills out points at the wrong answer.
- penalty that may be imposed for furnishing false information that decreases the withholding amount
- $500
- for the employee to notify the employer of any substantial change in the percentage of services performed within New York State, or a change from nonresident to resident
- 10 days
Source: Form IT-2104.1, revised December 2024.
The employer withholds on the percentage supplied, must keep the certificate, and must have it available for inspection by the Tax Department.
Remote schedules change, so the certificate is a recurring obligation, not a hire-date form.
Nebraska runs the same pattern with a different form. Form 9N asks the nonresident employee to designate the percentage of wages subject to Nebraska withholding, and the employer withholds on what the employee certifies.
Which factors an employer can actually change
Employer-controlled and inexpensive: written condition of employment language, a documented business purpose for the location, and no designated office space at a regular place of business. Employer-controlled and expensive: reimbursement at 80 percent or more, which carries real spend and, under an accountable plan, keeps the payment out of wages. Outside anyone’s control: specialized facilities and whether the employer sells at wholesale or retail.
What to do this week
A certificate challenged three years from now is defended with records that existed at the time. For resident and nonresident withholding outside the convenience rule, see the multi-state payroll tax guide.
Frequently asked questions
Does a qualifying home office mean the employee owes no New York tax?
No. It changes how work days are allocated. Days worked in New York remain New York source income.
Does the convenience rule apply if the employee's main office is outside New York?
No. The test engages only when the assigned or primary work location is an established office of the employer inside New York State.
How many factors does a home office need?
Either the primary factor alone, or at least four of the six secondary factors together with at least three of the other factors.
Who decides, the employer or the employee?
The employee certifies the allocation percentage on Form IT-2104.1 and the employer withholds on it. The employer keeps the certificate and must have it available for inspection.
This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.