Last updated: November 2026

OnPay Review 2026: Pricing and Features

OnPay costs $49 a month plus $6 per worker, as listed in September 2026. It files payroll taxes in all 50 states, charges nothing extra for workers in more than one state, and backs its work with an error-free guarantee.

The right fit for OnPay

If you want full-service payroll without comparing plan tiers, OnPay belongs on your shortlist. Accounting firms managing payroll for multiple clients get an accountant dashboard that shows every client and upcoming payroll deadlines in one place.

The platform handles hourly, tipped, and contract workers in the same payroll run. You can set multiple pay schedules and different pay rates for individual employees at no extra fee. OnPay also offers pay-as-you-go workers compensation through its partner ERGO NEXT, and deducts the premiums each time you run payroll.

What OnPay charges and what you actually get

OnPay's payroll plan is Payroll Essentials, and each worker paid in a month can be a W-2 employee or a 1099 contractor. There are no setup fees, no implementation charges, and no per-state surcharges for multi-state payroll. The company will import your employee data from your previous provider at no cost. Three optional monthly add-ons, including a human resources (HR) add-on, are priced separately.

OnPay's payroll plan and add-ons, as listed in September 2026
ProductMonthly priceWhat it covers
Payroll Essentials$49 plus $6 per worker paid that monthUnlimited payroll runs, federal, state and local tax filing, W-2 and 1099 preparation, new-hire reporting, benefits administration and employee self-service
HR add-on$15 plus $2 per workerPaid time off management, onboarding workflows and org charts
Compliance Resources$10State-by-state compliance alerts and resources
Live HR Support$65HR support that OnPay says is backed by licensed HR experts
a month for 10 employees
$109
a month for 25 employees
$199
a month for 50 employees
$349

Payroll Essentials alone, at September 2026 rates.

Benefits, support and the error-free guarantee

OnPay's in-house licensed brokers help you choose and set up health, dental, vision, and life insurance plans. OnPay also offers 401(k) plans through partner providers, plus flexible spending accounts, health savings accounts, and commuter benefits. Premiums are deducted from payroll automatically. OnPay states that it handles ongoing plan administration at no additional cost.

You get dedicated onboarding support, then phone, email, and chat support from 9 AM to 8 PM Eastern time on weekdays, as listed in October 2026.

Tipped employees and Square point-of-sale users

Restaurants and retail businesses with tipped employees who use Square's point-of-sale system can consider Square Payroll. It imports timecards from that system and tracks direct tips. OnPay calculates tipped wages, helps with minimum wage tip setup, and prepares Form 8846 for you to file.

OnPay's integration list

OnPay names a short list of integrations. It connects with QuickBooks Online, QuickBooks Desktop, and Xero for accounting, plus a handful of time-tracking tools like When I Work and QuickBooks Time. By their own September 2026 counts, Gusto integrates with more than 150 third-party apps and Rippling with 650 or more.

How OnPay compares to the alternatives

Against Gusto, OnPay wins on price for multi-state payroll. Both providers file Form 941 quarterly and handle year-end W-2s.

OnPay and Gusto for multi-state payroll, as listed in September 2026
PlanMonthly priceMulti-state payroll
OnPay Payroll Essentials$49 plus $6 per workerIncluded at no extra charge
Gusto Simple$49 plus $6 per personNot available; Simple is single-state payroll
Gusto Plus$80 plus $12 per personIncluded
OnPay a month for a 15-employee multi-state business
$139
Gusto Plus a month for the same business
$260
a year less with OnPay
$1,452

At September 2026 rates.

Against ADP, OnPay publishes its rate. ADP does not publish pricing.

Patriot Software's Full Service Payroll plan is $37 per month plus $5 per worker paid, as listed in September 2026. Each additional state filing adds $12 per month, a charge OnPay does not make. Comparing payroll provider options helps you make this tradeoff with real numbers instead of marketing claims.

What to do next

Start by comparing your current provider's total annual cost against OnPay's published rate using the numbers above, and see what the difference buys you. Read our breakdown of Gusto's full pricing structure.

Frequently asked questions

How much does OnPay cost per month?

As listed in September 2026, OnPay's payroll plan costs $49 per month plus $6 per worker paid that month, whether a W-2 employee or a 1099 contractor. There are no setup fees and no per-state charges. Three optional monthly add-ons are priced separately: a human resources add-on at $15 plus $2 per worker, Compliance Resources at $10, and Live HR Support at $65.

Is OnPay better than Gusto for small business?

At September 2026 rates, OnPay costs less than Gusto for businesses with employees in more than one state. In one state, Gusto Simple and OnPay share the same $49 plus $6 per-person rate. For multi-state payroll, Gusto's Plus plan costs $80 plus $12 per person, while OnPay stays at $49 plus $6. Gusto lists more third-party integrations.

Does OnPay handle multi-state payroll?

Yes. OnPay files federal, state, and local payroll taxes in all 50 states at no additional charge. There is no multi-state surcharge and no plan upgrade required. This is included in the base $49 plus $6 per-worker pricing, as listed in September 2026.

What are the downsides of OnPay?

Paid time off management, onboarding workflows and org charts sit in a separate, paid human resources add-on.

Does OnPay offer benefits administration?

Yes. OnPay's in-house licensed brokers help you set up health, dental, vision, and life insurance, and OnPay offers 401(k), flexible spending account, health savings account, and commuter benefit plans. Premiums are deducted from payroll automatically, and OnPay handles ongoing plan administration at no additional cost.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.