Last updated: November 2026

Gusto Alternatives Compared for 2026

If you're leaving, you should know exactly why.

Before you compare alternatives, log into Gusto and check what you actually use. If you're on the Simple plan with basic biweekly payroll, an alternative that still files your taxes, such as Patriot Full Service Payroll for 10 people, can save you money. If you're on Plus with time tracking, paid time off management, and health insurance administration, make sure your replacement includes all of that before you count the savings.

What Gusto Plus Includes

Gusto Plus base fee per month
$80
added per person each month on Gusto Plus
$12

Gusto rates as listed in September 2026.

A company on Plus is getting payroll, tax filing, health insurance administration, time tracking, paid time off management, new hire reporting, W-2 and 1099 filing, and employee self-service.

OnPay

As listed in September 2026, OnPay's base payroll plan, Payroll Essentials, costs $49 per month plus $6 per worker. Three add-ons are priced separately.

OnPay add-ons, as listed in September 2026
Add-onPrice
Human resources (HR) add-on$15 base plus $2 per worker
Compliance Resources$10 base
Live HR Support$65 base
OnPay and Gusto for a 15-person company
PlanCost per monthPayroll in more than one state
OnPay$139Included in OnPay's plan
Gusto Simple$139Not on Simple: Gusto sells Simple for single-state payroll and puts multi-state payroll on Plus
Gusto Plus$260Included on Plus

OnPay and Gusto as listed in September 2026.

Against Gusto Plus, OnPay saves a 15-person company $1,452 per year. OnPay handles payroll processing, tax filing, direct deposit, benefits administration, W-2 and 1099 filing, and new hire reporting.

Rippling

Rippling's modular pricing means your cost grows as you add products. Rippling publishes no total price: as listed in November 2026, Rippling says it gives a custom quote based on your company's needs.

Justworks

Justworks professional employer organization plans, as listed in November 2026
PlanPrice per employee per monthWhat the plan includes
PEO Basic$79Payroll, access to workers' comp, federal and state compliance alerts, and standard HR consulting
PEO Plus$124Everything in PEO Basic, plus access to medical, dental and vision insurance

Both plans are expensive compared to Gusto's $6 to $22 per person, as listed in September 2026, but the comparison isn't apples to apples. See our Gusto vs Justworks comparison for the full professional employer organization (PEO) analysis before making this jump.

Patriot Software

Patriot payroll plans, as listed in September 2026
PlanPricePayroll tax filing
Full Service Payroll$37 per month plus $5 per workerPatriot handles federal and state tax filing
Basic Payroll$17 per month plus $4 per workerYou file all payroll taxes yourself
a month on Patriot Full Service Payroll for a 10-person company
$87
a month on Gusto Simple for the same 10 people
$109
saved over a year on Patriot, against Gusto Simple
$264

Patriot and Gusto as listed in September 2026.

Patriot also handles payroll processing, direct deposit, and W-2 preparation. Patriot integrates with named partners, SimplyInsured for employee health benefits and Vestwell for 401(k), and it tracks time off accruals. Gusto administers health insurance inside the payroll platform on Simple, Plus and Premium.

Paychex Flex: if you want a choice of support level

Paychex offers three support levels: self-service online access, on-demand support with available representatives, and dedicated assigned payroll specialists. Paychex Basic, Foundations, Advanced and Complete are each priced on request, so none carries a published rate.

Premium Customer Support on each Paychex plan
PlanPremium Customer Support
BasicAn add-on
FoundationsAn add-on
AdvancedAn add-on
CompleteIncluded

QuickBooks Payroll (QB): payroll only at three published rates

Intuit sells payroll on its own in three plans.

QB Workforce plans, list prices as listed in September 2026
PlanBase fee per monthPer employee per month
QB Workforce Payroll$50$7
QB Workforce Premium$88$13
QB Workforce Elite$134$17

How to switch from Gusto without breaking anything

A switch at the start of a quarter keeps your quarterly Form 941 filing clean, because one provider handles the full quarter. January 1 is the cleanest quarter start. At any other quarter start, the new system needs each employee's year-to-date figures, because the Social Security wage base limit applies for the whole year.

Explore all your options in the payroll provider reviews, pricing, and comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch from Gusto to another provider mid-year?

Yes. Switch at the start of a quarter, ideally January 1. Export each employee's year-to-date wages and taxes from Gusto, by quarter, and provide them to your new provider. Before you cancel Gusto, enter one payroll in the new system without submitting it. Compare gross pay, each tax and deduction, and net pay for every employee against what Gusto calculated for the same period.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.