Last updated: November 2026
Do I need workers comp insurance?
In California and Illinois, one employee is enough to require workers comp insurance. Texas and Wyoming leave many private employers free to choose. The real question is whether your situation falls into an exemption your state allows, and whether relying on it is worth the risk.
The state requirement
| State | When coverage is required |
|---|---|
| California | Required even if you have only one employee. |
| Illinois | Required with one employee, even a part-time one, and that employee must be insured from the moment of hire. |
| New York | Required for virtually all employers. A person who works under your supervision, direction and control, on or off your premises, counts as your employee. |
| Alabama | Not required if you regularly employ fewer than five, counting full-time and part-time employees and corporate officers. That exemption does not apply to building new single-family homes. |
| Florida | Construction employers need coverage with one employee. Other employers need it once they have four. |
| Texas | Not required for most private employers. Employers without it, called non-subscribers, must report to the state that they do not have coverage. |
| Wyoming | Required through the Department of Workforce Services before work begins, for businesses in an extra-hazardous industry. Other businesses may choose coverage. |
New York also counts seasonal and temporary workers, volunteers, and family members, paid or unpaid, at a for-profit business. Illinois requires family members to be insured too, unless they are corporate officers or work for a farm under the state’s size limit.
The Texas Department of Insurance says coverage limits liability if an employee sues the business, except when gross negligence results in a fatality.
Exemptions that exist and exemptions people wish existed
If you work alone, you have no employees to cover. Workers comp for sole proprietors and limited liability company (LLC) owners still depends on the state.
| State | Sole proprietors | LLC members |
|---|---|---|
| New York | Not required with no employees, though a sole proprietor may buy coverage voluntarily. | Not counted as employees, so an LLC without employees needs no coverage. |
| Illinois | Sole proprietors and business partners may choose whether to come under the state’s law. | Members may exempt themselves. |
| California | A roofer with no employees must still carry coverage. | Working members who receive wages are employees. A managing member may elect to be excluded if they meet the criteria in Labor Code section 3352. |
| Florida | In construction, a sole proprietor counts as an employee. | In construction, no more than three officers may elect to be exempt, and a member owning at least 10 percent counts as an officer. |
Workers comp for sole proprietors who sub for general contractors (GCs) is a different situation entirely. New York’s board says GCs routinely require subcontractors to show proof of their own workers comp coverage. As a result, many sole proprietors with no employees, not otherwise required to carry a policy, buy one to work for a particular GC. Without that proof, insurance carriers often charge the GC premium for coverage of every subcontractor on the job site. In Florida, a contractor must require a subcontractor to provide evidence of workers’ compensation insurance.
Florida counts an independent contractor working or performing services in the construction industry as an employee. California presumes a worker is an employee unless the hiring business satisfies all three conditions of its ABC test. New York’s construction law presumes a worker is a contractor’s employee unless the contractor proves all three of its own criteria. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) weighs control and independence in three categories in its worker classification guidelines: behavioral, financial and the type of relationship.
Workers comp for 1099 workers becomes your problem if the state or the carrier determines the worker was misclassified.
What happens if you skip it and get caught
Penalties for operating without required workers compensation insurance vary by state. In New York, California and Illinois they include fines, criminal charges, personal liability and orders to stop work.
| State | Penalties | Personal liability |
|---|---|---|
| New York | Up to $2,000 for each 10-day period without coverage, as listed in October 2026. Failing to cover more than five employees within 12 months is a felony, with a fine of $5,000 to $50,000. | The sole proprietor, the partners, or a corporation’s president, secretary and treasurer are personally liable for the failure to insure. |
| California | The greater of twice the premium you would have paid while uninsured or $1,500 per employee, according to the state’s employer FAQ dated March 2023. | You pay all bills related to an employee’s work injury or illness, and the employee can also file a civil action against you. |
| Illinois | An employer found to have knowingly gone uninsured can be ordered to stop all business operations until it shows proof of insurance. | If you knowingly went uninsured, the employee can sue in civil court, where benefits are unlimited and you must prove you were not negligent. |
The gray areas that need professional answers
Domestic and household employees. Alabama does not require coverage for domestic employees, though employers may elect it. New York requires it for a domestic worker employed 40 or more hours a week by the same employer. New York does not require it if every domestic worker works under 40 hours a week for the household and none lives on the premises. Workers comp sits alongside the federal nanny payroll taxes: different rules, separate filings.
Agricultural workers. Alabama does not require coverage for farm laborers, but New York requires it for every farm that has employees. New York does not count a farmer’s spouse and minor children as employees unless they work under an express contract of hire. Agricultural employers should check their specific state’s workers compensation program rules.
Religious organizations. New York requires a nonprofit that pays people to cover them, with exceptions. The exceptions include clergy performing only religious duties, and teachers and non-manual staff at religious, charitable or educational institutions. A church’s paid maintenance crew does manual work, so it falls outside those exceptions.
Real estate agents. New York does not require coverage for a licensed real estate agent paid on sales rather than hours under a written independent contractor agreement. California requires real estate brokers to provide workers compensation coverage for their sales agents.
What to do this week
The certificates matter at audit time. At a New York State Insurance Fund workers comp audit, premium is recalculated to include any subcontractor whose coverage documents you cannot produce.
Compare your current workers comp cost against your state’s penalty schedule for non-compliance. If the premium feels expensive, look at pay as you go workers comp to spread the cost based on actual payroll.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need workers comp if I only have one employee?
In California and Illinois, yes, and Illinois counts a part-time employee. Florida requires it with one employee in construction and with four elsewhere. Alabama does not require it below five regularly employed employees, except in building new single-family homes. Texas lets most private employers choose. Check your specific state's threshold, but assume you need coverage unless you have confirmed otherwise.
Do I need workers comp if I am a sole proprietor with no employees?
Not in New York, and Illinois lets you choose. California is stricter for roofers, who must carry coverage even with no employees. Florida counts a sole proprietor in the construction industry as an employee. You may still need a ghost policy if a general contractor or client requires proof of coverage as a condition of hiring you.
What happens if I do not have workers comp and an employee gets hurt?
In California, you are responsible for paying all bills related to the injury or illness, and the employee can also file a civil action against you. In New York, the sole proprietor, the partners, or a corporation's president, secretary and treasurer are personally liable. New York's penalties, as listed in October 2026, run up to $2,000 for each 10-day period without coverage. Failing to cover more than five employees within a 12-month period is a felony there.
Do 1099 contractors count toward my workers comp requirement?
Florida counts an independent contractor working or performing services in the construction industry as an employee. In New York, a State Insurance Fund audit recalculates your premium to include any subcontractor whose coverage documents you cannot produce. Collect a workers comp certificate from every 1099 contractor to protect against this risk.
This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.