Last updated: November 2026

How to Run Payroll Yourself (And When to Stop)

You can do your own payroll taxes for about $21 a month in 2026. That is the software price for one employee.

Do-it-yourself (DIY) payroll fits a narrow window: one to three employees in one state, simple hourly or salary wages with no tips or commissions, and comfort filing tax forms. Here is how to do it correctly, what it actually involves, and the exact point where doing payroll without a service stops making sense.

Federal and state accounts come first

Before you pay anyone, you need an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Apply online at irs.gov and you will have it in minutes. You also need a state unemployment insurance account in every state where your employees work, plus a state withholding tax account unless that state has no individual income tax. Some states combine these into one registration.

In California, one registration with the Employment Development Department (EDD) gives you an eight-digit employer payroll tax account number. You use that number for every payroll tax return, wage report and payment you file with the EDD. A workers comp policy is separate.

Paperwork and bank setup before the first paycheck

Federal law sets that 20-day limit, and some states require the report sooner. These reports feed the child support enforcement system. A state that fines employers for not reporting can charge up to $25 per new hire, or up to $500 when the employer and employee conspire not to report.

Gross to net is where DIY breaks or holds

For a salaried employee paid biweekly, divide the annual salary by 26 to get gross pay. For hourly employees, multiply hours by rate and add overtime at 1.5 times the regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. That is the easy part.

From gross pay, you withhold federal income tax using the IRS withholding tables in Publication 15-T, and any state income tax using your state's tables or formula. The federal amount depends on the wages, the pay period, and the information on the employee's Form W-4.

Social Security tax withheld from the employee, plus a matching 6.2% from you, on wages up to $184,500 in 2026 and $192,300 in 2027
6.2%
Medicare tax withheld from the employee, plus a matching 1.45% from you, on all wages with no cap
1.45%
Federal unemployment tax you pay on the first $7,000 per employee in 2026
6.0%

Source: IRS Publication 15, 2026 rates; Social Security Administration for the 2027 wage base.

Federal unemployment tax drops to 0.6% if you qualify for the maximum 5.4% credit, which starts with paying state unemployment taxes in full and on time. You pay state unemployment tax at a rate assigned by your state. Texas, for example, assigns new employers 2.70% in 2026 on the first $9,000 of each employee's wages.

A pre-tax benefit can be exempt from one payroll tax and still subject to another, so taxable wages can differ from one tax to the next.

How two common pre-tax benefits are taxed federally
BenefitFederal income tax withholdingSocial Security and MedicareFederal unemployment tax
Elective 401(k) deferralsGenerally exempt, subject to the section 402(g) limitTaxableTaxable
Health insurance premiums under a plan for employeesExempt, except for 2% shareholder-employees of S corporationsExemptExempt

Source: IRS Publication 15.

Health insurance premiums an employee pays through a section 125 cafeteria plan are treated the same way, as long as the employee chooses the benefit rather than cash.

Tips change the gross-to-net calculation because the employer must ensure the employee earns at least minimum wage after the tip credit. Social Security and Medicare taxes also apply to reported tips.

Late payroll tax deposits draw a graduated penalty

Before each calendar year, you determine your deposit schedule: monthly or semi-weekly. Monthly depositors must deposit employment taxes on payments made during a month by the 15th of the following month, and semi-weekly depositors follow a Wednesday/Friday split based on payday.

Failure to deposit penalty by how late the deposit is
How latePenalty
1 to 5 calendar days2% of the unpaid deposit
6 to 15 calendar days5% of the unpaid deposit
More than 15 calendar days10% of the unpaid deposit
More than 10 calendar days after the first IRS notice, or the day a notice demands immediate payment15% of the unpaid deposit

The tiers do not stack, so a deposit more than fifteen calendar days late is charged 10% rather than 10% added to 2% and 5%.

You deposit federal payroll taxes electronically, through the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS), IRS Direct Pay or your IRS business tax account. If you indicated a federal tax obligation when you requested your EIN, you are pre-enrolled in EFTPS, and the IRS mails your personal identification number (PIN) separately. The IRS says to allow up to two weeks after you get your EIN before making tax deposits electronically.

Quarterly and annual filings stack up fast

Federal payroll filings run on a fixed calendar, and Form 941 comes due every quarter.

Federal payroll filings and their due dates
FormWhat it coversDue
Form 941Total wages, tips, federal income tax withheld, and Social Security and Medicare taxes for the quarterApril 30, July 31, October 31 and January 31
Form 940Federal unemployment tax for the yearJanuary 31
Form W-2Each employee's 2026 wages, furnished to the employee and filed with the Social Security AdministrationFebruary 1, 2027
Form 1099-NECContractors paid $600 or more in 2025, $2,000 or more in 2026, or $2,100 or more in 2027, filed with the IRSJanuary 31

Miss the 941 filing deadline and the penalty is 5% of unpaid tax for each month or part of a month, generally up to 25%. Filing Forms W-2 late carries a separate penalty for each form.

per Form W-2 filed up to 30 days late
$60
per form filed 31 days late through August 1
$130
per form filed after August 1, or not filed
$340

For Forms W-2 due in 2026 or 2027.

For a 5-employee company, filing Forms W-2 due in 2026 or 2027 seven months late costs $1,700 in filing penalties. The IRS charges a separate penalty for failing to provide employees correct copies on time.

What DIY payroll actually costs you

The monthly software cost is low.

Patriot Software payroll plans, as listed in September 2026
PlanPriceWhat it doesWho files the taxes
Basic Payroll$17 per month plus $4 per worker paidCalculates payroll and prints checksYou file all taxes yourself
Full Service Payroll$37 per month plus $5 per worker paidEverything in Basic PayrollPatriot files and deposits federal, state and local payroll taxes

On Full Service Payroll you are technically using a payroll provider, not doing payroll yourself.

The exact point where you should stop

As listed in September 2026, Gusto Simple and OnPay are each $49 a month plus $6 per employee. That is $79 per month for 5 employees. Gusto Simple, a single-state plan, files and pays federal and state payroll taxes automatically and includes Forms W-2, state new hire reporting and direct deposits.

Switch at the start of a quarter so a single Form 941 period does not split across two systems. A new business can compare payroll providers for startups.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to run payroll yourself?

Yes. No law requires you to use a payroll provider. You are legally responsible for calculating wages correctly, withholding the right taxes, depositing those taxes on time, and filing all required returns. The obligation is the same whether you do it or a provider does it.

Can I do payroll myself with just a spreadsheet?

You can use a spreadsheet to calculate gross-to-net wages. You still need to deposit taxes electronically, file 941s with the IRS, file state returns, and file W-2s with the Social Security Administration. A spreadsheet handles the math, but it does not handle any of the compliance, filing, or deposits.

What happens if I make a payroll tax mistake?

Late deposits draw penalties starting at 2% of the unpaid deposit, reaching 15% when the tax is still unpaid more than ten days after the first IRS notice. Filing Form 941 late draws a separate penalty. Interest accrues daily on any unpaid balance. Correcting an error on a filed Form 941 requires Form 941-X, paying the balance, and sometimes requesting penalty abatement.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.