Last updated: November 2026
Workers comp audit: what happens, how to prepare, how to fight the bill
Your workers compensation audit is not optional and it is not a formality. In Texas, every workers comp policy is subject to a final payroll audit, and the carrier uses the results to adjust your workers comp premium retroactively.

How the workers compensation audit works
When you purchase a workers comp policy, the carrier estimates your annual premium based on the payroll numbers you provide. The carrier assigns class codes to your business, applies the rate per $100 of payroll for each code, and calculates your estimated premium. You pay that estimated premium annually or in installments. After the policy term ends, the carrier audits your payroll to set the final premium.
| What the audit finds | What happens to the premium |
|---|---|
| Actual payroll higher than estimated | You owe the difference in premium |
| Actual payroll lower than estimated | You get a credit |
| Employees misclassified into a lower-rate class code | The auditor moves them to the correct code and charges the higher rate retroactively for the audited period |
What the auditor actually looks at
New York's State Insurance Fund asks for these records, including your quarterly Form 941 filings.
| Type of record | What New York asks for |
|---|---|
| Payroll | Your payroll book |
| Payroll tax returns | Form 941, and New York's NYS-45 and NYS-45 ATT |
| Employee tax forms | W-2 and W-3; 1099 and 1096 |
| Cash records | Cash book, check book or day book with cash expenses |
| Accounts | General ledger |
| Income tax returns | Form 1120, 1065, 1040 or 990 |
| Subcontractors | Certificates of insurance for the subcontractors you used |
| Contracts | Contracts, bills and invoices for labor, services and materials |
In Texas, auditable payroll includes commissions, bonuses, overtime pay, and holiday and vacation pay. The value of meals and lodging received as part of pay counts to the extent your records show it. In New York and Texas, overtime counts only at the straight-time rate, as long as your records show overtime pay separately for each employee and totaled by classification. If you paid an employee $20 per hour base and $30 per hour overtime, the auditor uses $20 for the overtime hours, not $30.
Payments to uninsured subcontractors get added to your auditable payroll in New York. If you hired a 1099 contractor who does not carry their own workers comp insurance, the auditor treats that payment as if it were payroll to your own employee. A $50,000 payment to an uninsured sub working under a construction class code rated at $12 per $100 adds $6,000 to your audit bill. The fix is to collect a workers comp certificate of insurance from every subcontractor before they start work.
The class code reclassification trap
Workers comp class codes determine your rate per $100 of payroll. Auditors reclassify employees when the job duties described on the policy do not match the actual work being performed. A construction company that lists a project manager as clerical (8810) when that person spends half their time on job sites (5606) will see them reclassified at the higher rate.
Construction is one of the exceptions to that rule. Texas allows an individual employee's payroll to be divided between construction classifications, but only with accurate records of the work each employee performed. An estimated or percentage allocation is not permitted. New York's State Insurance Fund also requires the separation to rest on actual time worked in each code, not on percentages.
Your experience modification rate (EMR) multiplies whatever the class code rate produces. If the audit reclassifies employees into higher-rated codes and your EMR is above 1.0, both multipliers stack.
- Base premium in the example
- $50,000
- Experience modification rate (EMR) in the example
- 1.15
- Added per year by that EMR
- $7,500
Example figures, not a published premium or modifier.
How to prepare before the auditor calls
Run your own internal audit first, so you know the numbers before the auditor tells you.
New York's State Insurance Fund lists the documents it needs in an appointment letter. After a missed appointment, insufficient records, or no response, it may conduct an estimated payroll verification instead, which can produce a higher premium than a proper verification would have.
Get the free printable workers' comp audit prep checklist: eight sections on class codes, excludable payroll, officer pay, subcontractor coverage, the experience mod worksheet, and the records to have ready. Enter your email and we'll send it to you.
How to dispute the audit results
Oregon's Department of Consumer and Business Services lists the common audit disputes as payroll amounts, worker classifications, and whether certain workers should have been included.
Oregon sets a 60-day deadline, and missing it can limit your options. Because of that deadline, the ombudsman often helps businesses take the first two steps at the same time. Keep copies of payroll records, contracts and audit documents, because they are often needed to resolve a dispute.
For a class code dispute, bring the official class code description, a written description of the employee's actual duties, and ideally a job description or organizational chart.
Avoiding surprises on the next audit
Switch to pay-as-you-go workers comp if your payroll fluctuates significantly. New York's State Insurance Fund offers PayGo, which aligns premium to your payroll each pay period, with payroll reported weekly, biweekly or monthly. The payroll verification at the end of the policy year still happens, and the reported payroll feeds into it, so premium no longer has to be estimated. The fund describes PayGo as keeping pace with the month-to-month flows of seasonal business.
Update your carrier midyear if you hire new employees, change job roles, or add subcontractors.
During the year, check the payroll on your payroll provider's reports against the estimate on your policy, not only at audit time.
Frequently asked questions
What is a workers comp audit?
A workers compensation audit is a review of your actual payroll conducted by your insurance carrier after your policy year ends. The carrier compares your real payroll, employee classifications, and subcontractor payments against the estimates used to calculate your premium. If actual numbers exceed estimates, you owe additional premium. If they are lower, you receive a credit.
Can I refuse a workers comp audit?
No. The standard workers comp policy requires you to let the carrier examine and audit your records. In New York, a missed appointment, insufficient records or no response can lead the State Insurance Fund to conduct an estimated payroll verification, which can produce a higher premium.
How do I dispute a workers comp audit?
Start with your carrier or agent and explain exactly what you disagree with, such as a misclassified employee or a subcontractor payment where the sub had their own coverage. Keep your payroll records, contracts and audit documents, because they are often needed to resolve the dispute. In Oregon, a 60-day deadline applies, and missing it can limit your options.
Why is my workers comp audit bill so high?
Common causes are payroll that grew beyond your estimate, employees reclassified into higher-rated class codes based on actual duties, and payments to uninsured subcontractors added to your auditable payroll. Review the audit worksheet line by line to identify which factor is driving the increase.
Does overtime affect my workers comp premium?
Overtime hours are included in auditable payroll, but in New York and Texas only at the straight-time rate, provided your records show overtime separately. If an employee earns $25 per hour base and $37.50 per hour overtime, the auditor should use $25 for the overtime hours. If your audit bill includes overtime at the premium rate, dispute it.
This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.