Last updated: November 2026

Best Payroll for Restaurants: What Each Provider Publishes

The wrong payroll company costs a restaurant owner more than the monthly fee. It costs them the Section 45B Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) tip credit they never claimed and the Form 8027 filing they did not know was due. The best payroll for restaurants is not the cheapest. It is the one that actually handles restaurant payroll correctly.

What restaurant payroll requires that normal payroll does not

Every restaurant payroll provider must handle five things that standard small business payroll does not touch. If a provider cannot do all five, it is not built for hospitality payroll.

Tip tracking and reporting. The provider must accept reported tip amounts from employees, include those tips as wages for FICA withholding, and track them separately for Form 8027 and Section 45B calculations.

FICA tip credit tracking. The payroll provider must track the data for the Section 45B credit. Your certified public accountant (CPA) claims the credit on your business return using Form 8846, but without accurate payroll data broken out by employee, the credit is impossible to calculate.

Tip credit calculation. In states that allow it, employers can pay tipped employees a cash wage below the standard minimum wage, with tips making up the difference. The provider must calculate and verify that each tipped employee's cash wage plus reported tips meets or exceeds the applicable minimum wage for every workweek. If tips fall short, the employer owes the difference.

Lowest federal cash wage per hour for a tipped employee when the employer takes the tip credit
$2.13
Federal minimum wage per hour on January 1, 2007. Tips used to reach it earn no Section 45B credit
$5.15

Sources: 29 CFR 531.50 and IRS Form 8846 (2025).

Your state may set a higher tipped minimum wage that overrides the federal floor. Restaurant payroll taxes lists the states that require the full minimum wage before tips.

Some employees work multiple positions at different rates within the same shift. Their regular rate for the workweek is the weighted average of those rates, with certain statutory exceptions, as weighted average overtime pay explains.

Service charge vs tip distinction. The payroll system must allow you to code service charge income separately from reported tips. Any part of a service charge paid out to an employee is wages, not a tip, as service charges versus tips explains.

Form 8027 preparation. Restaurants where tipping is customary must file it each year if they employed more than 10 workers on a typical business day the year before. The rule covers food or drinks served for consumption on the premises, and counter service where customers carry the food away is excluded. Restaurant payroll taxes covers what the form reports and how the 8% tip allocation works.

The payroll provider should either generate Form 8027 directly or provide a report that gives your accountant the exact data needed to complete it. If a provider does not file it, you need to file it yourself or pay your accountant to do it.

How the major providers handle restaurant payroll

What Gusto and OnPay say they do for restaurant payroll
RequirementGusto saysOnPay says
Tipped workers short of minimum wageIt can adjust wages automatically to comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act tip credit and minimum wage requirement, if you choose that settingIts built-in tip makeup feature automates the calculation when a worker's wages and tips fall short of minimum wage
Section 45B FICA tip creditIt supplies a year-end report with the details your accountant needs for Section 45BForm 8846 is among the tax filings and payments it automates
Extra payroll runsOff-cycle payroll runs carry no extra chargePricing includes unlimited pay runs, so running payroll two or four times a month costs the same

OnPay also says it handles tips as a separate pay item. Its rate is published: one monthly fee plus a per-employee fee, with optional human resources add-ons priced separately.

Gusto

Gusto lists integrations with Clover, Homebase, and 7shifts. As listed in September 2026, the Plus plan at $80 per month plus $12 per person includes time tracking.

Square Payroll

As listed in September 2026, Square Payroll costs $35 per month plus $6 per person paid.

Square Payroll: what is included, fees and add-ons
ItemSquare Payroll
IncludedTimecard import from Square POS, direct tip tracking, federal and state tax filing, direct deposit, and digital W-2 delivery
Paper W-2 copies$3 per mailed form, a yearly fee if you opt in to mailing
Add-ons with no price shownHealth insurance and 401(k) retirement benefits

Square, as listed in September 2026.

RUN Powered by ADP

ADP lists its Wage Garnishment Payment Service on the Enhanced package and above, not on Essential. ADP publishes no price for any of the four RUN Powered by ADP packages.

The features that actually matter for restaurant payroll management

Point of sale integration. Manual tip entry invites mistakes that cascade into incorrect withholding, incorrect 8027 data, and incorrect Section 45B calculations.

Off-cycle run pricing. Tip corrections mean adjustment runs. If your provider charges per off-cycle run, multiply that by your runs per year and add it to your annual cost.

Workers comp integration. Pay as you go workers comp through payroll integration is the cleanest setup for restaurants with variable staffing levels.

What to do before switching providers

Check your POS integration first.

Pull your last three years of payroll data and check whether your current provider tracked Section 45B FICA tip credit data. If the data exists but your CPA never claimed the credit, file amended returns.

Before you cancel your current provider, enter one payroll in the new system without submitting it. Compare gross pay, the tip credit, FICA on tips, every other tax and deduction, and net pay for each employee against what your current provider calculated for the same period. If the numbers do not match, find out why before committing.

Any provider that cannot answer all five clearly is not ready for restaurant payroll taxes.

Frequently asked questions

How do I handle tip pooling in payroll?

Federal rules allow mandatory tip pools among customarily tipped employees. Cooks and dishwashers can join only when every worker gets a cash wage of at least the federal minimum wage.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.