Last updated: November 2026

Payroll for Startups: How Five Providers Compare

Startup payroll has specific requirements that separate it from generic small business payroll. Founders paying themselves through an S corporation need officer compensation set up correctly on Day 1. Contractor payments alongside W-2 employees need 1099 tracking from the start, not bolted on at year-end. And all of this needs to connect to your accounting software so your bookkeeper isn't reconciling payroll by hand every month.

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) says on its Employer Identification Number page that you need one if you have employees.

Published monthly prices for payroll software from Gusto, OnPay and QuickBooks
PlanBase fee per monthPer person, per monthAs listed in
Gusto Simple$49$6 per personSeptember 2026
Gusto Plus$80$12 per personSeptember 2026
OnPay$49$6 per workerSeptember 2026
OnPay human resources add-on, on top of the OnPay price$15$2 per workerSeptember 2026
QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, the entry plan$50$7 per employeeSeptember 2026
QuickBooks Workforce Premium$88$13 per employeeSeptember 2026
a month on Gusto Simple for a five-person startup
$79
a month on OnPay for a three-person startup
$67

At the rates in the table above, before add-ons, as listed in September 2026.

Gusto

Gusto's Simple plan handles payroll processing, tax filing, W-2 and 1099 preparation, new hire reporting, and employee self-service. Its price includes federal and state tax deposits, quarterly Form 941 filings and state unemployment filings.

What Gusto Simple and Plus include, as listed in September 2026
FeatureSimplePlus
StatesSingle-state payroll onlyMulti-state payroll
Next-day payAdd-onIncluded
Time trackingAdd-onIncluded
State tax registration in a new stateAdd-on, priced by state with no published figureAdd-on, priced by state with no published figure
Health insurance administrationIncludedIncluded
Contractor payments and Forms 1099Included, at the same per-person fee as employeesIncluded, at the same per-person fee as employees

Rippling

Rippling says its human resources software automates onboarding, from offer letters to device shipping. It says new hires, salary changes and benefits deductions flow automatically into payroll.

As listed in November 2026, Rippling says its plans start at $8 per employee per month, with a monthly base fee. It sends a custom quote for the products you choose. As listed the same month, Rippling says its startup program gives eligible US startups backed by venture capital free access for 6 months, depending on funding status and stage.

Most Rippling products are priced per employee per month. Check our Gusto vs Rippling comparison for the detailed breakdown.

Justworks

Justworks' professional employer organization (PEO) plan named PEO Basic is $79 per employee per month as of September 2026. The PEO Plus plan at $124 per employee per month adds access to medical, dental and vision insurance. Expensive compared to Gusto, but if health insurance is the difference between landing your first three engineers and losing them to a company with a benefits package, the math changes. The tradeoff: your employees are co-employed by Justworks. Read the full PEO breakdown before signing.

OnPay

Payroll, tax filing, benefits administration, multi-state support, W-2 and 1099 filing and contractor payments are in OnPay's base plan. Human resources tools such as paid time off management and org charts are a separate add-on.

QuickBooks Payroll (QB)

Intuit says QuickBooks automatically creates default accounts where your payroll liabilities and expenses are recorded. You can customize those accounts to meet your accounting needs.

The startup payroll mistake that costs real money

Some founders pay themselves as contractors instead of employees to save on payroll taxes. They take draws or issue themselves a 1099 to avoid the employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes. If your company is taxed as an S corporation, the IRS says it must pay you reasonable compensation for your services before non-wage distributions may be made to you. The IRS paying yourself guidance says an officer of a corporation is generally an employee.

What to do next

See other providers in our payroll provider reviews, pricing, and comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

When should a startup start using payroll software?

The day you pay an employee, including yourself if you are an officer of a corporation. The IRS says a corporate officer is generally an employee with wages subject to withholding. Set it up before your first payment, not after.

Should startup founders use a PEO?

Only if health insurance costs are blocking your ability to hire. PEOs like Justworks offer benefits through the PEO, but Justworks is listed as a co-employer. Justworks charges $79 to $124 per employee per month as of September 2026, and only the $124 PEO Plus plan includes medical, dental and vision insurance. If you can recruit without employer-sponsored health insurance, standard payroll software saves money and keeps your employment structure simpler.

Is OnPay a suitable payroll option for startups?

OnPay fits a startup that wants one published price and pays both employees and contractors, in one state or several. As listed in September 2026, OnPay charges $49 a month plus $6 per worker, or $67 a month for three workers. Payroll, tax filing, benefits administration, multi-state support, W-2 and 1099 filing and contractor payments are in that base plan. OnPay says there are no added fees for workers in more than one state or for year-end W-2 and 1099 forms. Human resources tools are a separate add-on at $15 a month plus $2 per worker. Before choosing, count your workers and your states, and price OnPay against Gusto Simple at the same headcount.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.