Last updated: November 2026

ADP vs Paychex: How the Two Compare

Neither ADP nor Paychex publishes a price, so pick on what each package includes.

How ADP and Paychex Price Payroll

Both companies use a quote-based sales model.

RUN Powered by ADP is ADP's small business payroll product, and ADP Workforce Now is the one for midsized and enterprise employers. Garnishment payments are not included in ADP's Essential and are an add-on with Paychex's Basic. RUN comes in four packages (HR means human resources), and Paychex has four payroll packages.

Garnishment payment service by package
ProviderPackageGarnishment payments
RUN Powered by ADPEssential (Payroll)Not included
RUN Powered by ADPEnhanced (Payroll)Included
RUN Powered by ADPComplete (Payroll & HR Plus)Included
RUN Powered by ADPHR Pro (Payroll & HR)Included
PaychexBasicAdd-on
PaychexFoundationsIncluded
PaychexAdvancedIncluded
PaychexCompleteIncluded

As listed in October 2026 for ADP and Paychex. ADP calls it Garnishment Payment Service; Paychex calls it Garnishment Payment Services.

Both companies file the same Form 941 to the same Internal Revenue Service on the same schedule. The difference is everything around it.

ADP says RUN lets you process payroll outside your regular schedule, though payroll fees increase with frequency. Paying a shorted employee before the next payday takes an extra run, and so does a separate bonus payroll in December.

Neither company publishes what implementation costs. As of 2020, ADP said implementing human capital management software is usually a one-time fee, charged up front. Confirm what the fee includes before making a purchase.

For RUN, ADP says no contract is required and service can be terminated at any time. ADP Workforce Now is sold by quote. A quote can include a price guarantee for a set number of years with increases built in, which is separate from the notice needed to cancel. Before signing, ask in writing for the guarantee period, any scheduled increases and the cancellation notice period.

General Ledger Export and the Tax Filing Promise

General ledger export and tax filing penalties at ADP and Paychex
ItemRUN Powered by ADPPaychex
General ledger exportADP's General Ledger Interface comes with every RUN package, Essential included. ADP describes it as exporting journal entries into accounting software or a generic output file without re-keying data.As of January 2023, Paychex said Paychex Flex General Ledger posts payroll data to accounting software including QuickBooks Online, Xero and Sage Intacct. Paychex added that an additional fee may apply based on services selected.
Tax filing penaltiesADP makes a tax filing promise on all four RUN packages: if it makes a tax filing error, it pays the resulting fines or penalties.Paychex describes Taxpay, its tax administration service, as reducing the risk of penalties for late or inaccurate payments.

Support at ADP and Paychex

ADP lists 24/7 Customer Support, by phone or online chat, on all four RUN packages. Paychex offers three support levels: Online Customer Support comes with Basic, Enhanced with Foundations and Advanced, and Premium, which adds a payroll specialist, with Complete.

Support included by package
ProviderPackageSupport included
RUN Powered by ADPEssential (Payroll)24/7 Customer Support
RUN Powered by ADPEnhanced (Payroll)24/7 Customer Support
RUN Powered by ADPComplete (Payroll & HR Plus)24/7 Customer Support
RUN Powered by ADPHR Pro (Payroll & HR)24/7 Customer Support
PaychexBasicOnline Customer Support
PaychexFoundationsEnhanced Customer Support
PaychexAdvancedEnhanced Customer Support
PaychexCompletePremium Customer Support, with a payroll specialist

As listed in October 2026 for ADP and Paychex. With Paychex Basic, Enhanced Customer Support and Premium Customer Support are add-ons; with Foundations and Advanced, Premium Customer Support is an add-on.

What to do next

We may earn a commission if you request a quote through the following link.

For the Paychex quote, use Paychex’s quote request page

If you want to see how other payroll providers compare, start with the payroll provider reviews, pricing, and comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

Is ADP or Paychex cheaper for small businesses?

Neither publishes pricing. ADP says RUN pricing depends on how often you run payroll, how many people you pay, and how often you add or remove payees. Each Paychex plan is priced on request. The comparison comes from two written quotes for the same headcount and services.

Can I switch from ADP to Paychex mid-year?

Yes, but timing matters. Switch at the start of a quarter to keep your quarterly 941 filing clean. Paychex says it works with you to balance your year-to-date payroll data and can often help pull it directly from your previous payroll company's system. Before you cancel ADP, enter one payroll in Paychex without submitting it. Compare gross pay, each tax and deduction, and net pay for every employee against what ADP calculated for the same period.

How do ADP and Paychex handle multi-state payroll?

Multi-jurisdiction Payroll is on all four RUN packages, with ADP handling the tax filing. It covers employees who work in more than one state or local jurisdiction in the same pay period. Paychex says it automatically manages the calculation, withholding, and remittance of taxes for every state where your employees work.

Are ADP and Paychex contracts hard to cancel?

For RUN, ADP says no contract is required and service can be terminated at any time. ADP Workforce Now is sold by quote. A quote can include a price guarantee for a set number of years with increases built in, which is separate from the notice needed to cancel. Before signing, ask in writing for the guarantee period, any scheduled increases and the cancellation notice period. Get Paychex's cancellation terms in writing before you sign.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.