Independent payroll compliance research.
PayrollDetective is an independent research project that builds free calculators and reference content. It is for the people who process payroll, pay payroll taxes, and manage workers comp, and for the workers who live with the results. Independent here means not owned by any payroll provider, broker or insurer.
The problem
Many payroll guides are published by companies that sell payroll.
Payroll providers, brokers and insurers publish payroll guidance alongside the products they sell. PayrollDetective covers the checks a reader can run on that work: provider fees, workers comp premiums, overtime calculations, bonus withholding and worker classification. We do not sell payroll services or workers comp insurance. We earn commissions on some links, and each of those pages says so above the link.
The approach
Calculators and sourced answers.
Every tool on this site does one thing. It takes specific inputs and returns a specific answer.
The guides answer questions such as these: How is overtime calculated? What does my workers comp class code mean? How do I claim excess Social Security withheld from two jobs? What do my W-2 box codes mean? Each question gets a real answer.
Four commitments
What this site will and will not do.
01
We will tell you when a result depends on an assumption you should confirm for your own situation.
The IRS, the Department of Labor, and 50 state agencies each have rules that change. When a tool cannot answer a question, it says so directly and points to the next step.
02
We will not recommend products we have no business recommending.
We will not place a link unless we believe the service is the right answer to a real question the reader is asking.
03
We will publish corrections when we are wrong.
Sometimes we will get something wrong. When a page is wrong, it is fixed and its Last updated date moves.
04
We do not sell data.
The site does not share email lists. The privacy policy lists the analytics it runs. We do not require an account to use any tool on this site.
Editorial standards
How we research and write.
We work from primary sources first.
Listen
Listen to most pages.
Most pages have a Listen button that reads the page aloud in a computer-generated voice. You can pause it and set the reading speed from 0.75 times to 2 times. On a wider screen, you can also jump to any section from the On this page list. Your speed is remembered in your own browser.
Last updated: November 2026