Last updated: November 2026

Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: How the Two Compare

Headcount won't settle this one. Between Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll (QB), the plan you need decides which costs less. The calculator below shows the cost for your team.

Pricing side by side

Estimated monthly cost at published list prices

Using this calculator means you agree to our Terms of Use.

Published list prices as of September 2026.

PlanHow it’s pricedMonthly costYearly cost
Gusto
Simple $49 a month, plus $6 a month per person$49 a month, plus $6 a month per person$109$1,308
Plus $80 a month, plus $12 a month per person$80 a month, plus $12 a month per person$200$2,400
Premium $180 a month, plus $22 a month per person$180 a month, plus $22 a month per person$400$4,800
QuickBooks Payroll
Workforce Payroll $50 a month, plus $7 a month per employee$50 a month, plus $7 a month per employee$120$1,440
Workforce Premium $88 a month, plus $13 a month per employee$88 a month, plus $13 a month per employee$218$2,616
Workforce Elite $134 a month, plus $17 a month per employee$134 a month, plus $17 a month per employee$304$3,648

Lowest to highest monthly list price, 1 to 1,000 people paid

  1. Simple · Gusto
  2. Workforce Payroll · QuickBooks Payroll
  3. Plus · Gusto
  4. Workforce Premium · QuickBooks Payroll
  5. Workforce Elite · QuickBooks Payroll
  6. Premium · Gusto

This order holds at every headcount from 1 to 1,000 people.

Estimate only. Check it against the official source before you rely on it.

Subscription prices only. State tax registration, add-ons, contractor fees, year-end forms, extra-state fees and promotions are not included unless shown. This is not legal or financial advice.

QuickBooks Payroll comes in three tiers, and Gusto sells three plans for employers: Simple, Plus and Premium.

What each tier includes, as listed in September 2026
TierQuickBooks PayrollGusto
EntryWorkforce Payroll: federal and state tax filing, next-day direct deposit, and workers' comp administration at an added feeSimple: next-day pay and time tracking available as paid add-ons
MiddleWorkforce Premium adds same-day direct deposit, time tracking, weekend support and certain local taxesPlus includes next-day pay and time tracking
TopWorkforce Elite adds a personal human resources (HR) advisor, expert setup and tax penalty protectionPremium adds a Dedicated Service Advisor and access to certified HR experts
Monthly cost at 10 employees, as listed in September 2026
TierQuickBooks PayrollGusto
EntryWorkforce Payroll, $120Simple, $109
MiddleWorkforce Premium, $218Plus, $200
TopWorkforce Elite, $304Premium, $400

Gusto includes health insurance administration on all three plans, at no extra cost when Gusto is the broker.

QuickBooks Payroll tax penalty protection

As listed in September 2026, QuickBooks Payroll's Workforce Elite plan includes tax penalty protection. Intuit states its terms two different ways, so confirm yours in writing.

Intuit's two statements of tax penalty protection, as listed in September 2026
TermFirst statementSecond statement
Who is eligibleElite users who completed expert review of their payroll tax setup and enrolled in e-services for automated tax payments and filingsWorkforce Elite users only, and Intuit adds that other conditions and restrictions apply
Which noticesNotices for payroll taxes QuickBooks paid and filed for your companyA tax notice
When to send itWithin 15 days of the noticeWithin 15 days of the notice
What Intuit coversThe payroll tax penalty and interest, up to $25,000 per yearThe payroll tax penalty, up to $25,000
Help with the agencyIntuit helps resolve the notice with the tax agencyIntuit cannot help resolve notices for customers in Collections with the Internal Revenue Service

For small business owners who have been burned by a late deposit of the taxes reported on Form 941, that protection has real dollar value. The IRS failure to deposit penalty is 10% of the unpaid deposit when it is more than 15 calendar days late. It rises to 15% more than 10 calendar days after the first IRS notice.

Benefits, 401(k) and integrations

Gusto lists health savings and flexible spending accounts, commuter benefits, and life and disability insurance as add-ons on every plan.

Intuit says its health insurance information comes from Intuit Insurance Services Inc., a licensed broker Intuit owns, through a partnership with Allstate Health Solutions. The broker is paid a fee by Allstate on referred clients.

Gusto sells its own 401(k), branded Gusto by Guideline. Advisory comes from Gusto Investment Services, LLC and recordkeeping from Gusto Retirement Services, LLC. It also connects to outside 401(k) providers.

Gusto 401(k) fees, as listed in September 2026
FeeWhat Gusto lists
Blended expense ratios for its managed portfolios.058% to .061% of assets under management
Assumed account fee, charged by Gusto Investment Services, LLC.25%
Estimated total fees for one of its managed portfoliosCan be under 0.31%

Gusto integrates with QuickBooks Online, Xero, and FreshBooks.

Your accounting setup and HR needs

If your certified public accountant (CPA) manages your books in QuickBooks Online and you have no need for benefits administration beyond basic health insurance, QuickBooks Payroll eliminates an integration point. If you are building an HR function and need benefits, onboarding, paid time off management, and org charts alongside payroll, Gusto Plus and Premium list all four. The Gusto review sets out the pricing and plan limits by tier.

What to do next

Check whether your accountant or bookkeeper has a preference.

Browse the payroll provider reviews, pricing, and comparisons, or read Gusto vs Rippling and Gusto vs Justworks, before deciding.

Frequently asked questions

Is QuickBooks Payroll cheaper than Gusto?

As listed in September 2026, at 10 employees QB Workforce Payroll is $120 per month against Gusto Simple at $109. QB Workforce Premium is $218 against Gusto Plus at $200. QuickBooks wins on price at the top tier, where QB Workforce Elite at $304 beats Gusto Premium at $400.

Can I use QuickBooks Payroll without QuickBooks Online?

Yes. QuickBooks Payroll can run standalone.

Does Gusto integrate with QuickBooks Online?

Yes. Gusto syncs payroll data to QuickBooks Online.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.