Last updated: November 2026

Payroll for New Business: The Mistakes That Cost You Before Your First Paycheck

New employers can face payroll penalties before they run their first check. Not from bad math. From state registration deadlines and family employment rules that change with your entity type.

The basic mechanics of setting up payroll are covered in our payroll setup guide.

The federal tax obligations are spelled out in Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Publication 15 (Circular E). This page covers what happens after you follow those steps correctly and still get hit with costs you did not expect.

First-time employer payroll taxes come with rules that an established employer has already set up: an assigned unemployment tax rate, state registration and quarterly federal filing.

Your state unemployment tax (SUTA) rate starts as an assigned new employer rate

New employers start on an assigned state unemployment tax rate.

2026 new employer state unemployment tax rates in three states
StateNew employer rateTaxable wages per employee
Idaho1.000%, the standard rateFirst $58,300
California3.4%First $7,000
New York4.025%, plus 0.075% for the Re-employment Service FundFirst $17,600

In California, new employers keep the 3.4% rate for two to three years. After that, the California rate varies, depending partly on how much you have paid in unemployment insurance benefits. In Idaho, new employers keep the standard rate for at least the first six calendar quarters.

Classifying your first hire

Paying your first worker as a 1099 contractor does not settle the question. Under the IRS common-law rules, a worker is generally your employee if you have the right to control what will be done and how it will be done. If an employer-employee relationship exists, it does not matter what it is called, so a contractor agreement does not change it.

Family employment rules depend on your entity type

Hiring your spouse or children can change which payroll taxes apply, depending on your business structure.

Federal payroll taxes on a family member's wages
Family member and employerIncome tax withholdingSocial Security and MedicareFederal unemployment tax (FUTA)
Your child, working in your sole proprietorship or in a partnership in which each partner is a parent of the childGenerally subjectNot subject while the child is under 18Not subject while the child is under 21
Your spouse, working in your trade or businessSubjectSubjectNot subject
Your child or spouse, working for a corporation (even one the parent or spouse controls), an estate, or a partnership (for a child, unless each partner is a parent)SubjectSubjectSubject

An S corporation that hires the owner’s 16-year-old child still owes Social Security and Medicare taxes on the child’s wages.

Form 941 in quarters with zero wages, and the seasonal exception

Unless you file a final return, you must keep filing Form 941 every quarter, even for quarters in which you paid no wages.

If you are running payroll yourself, you must remember to file these zero-wage returns. You need a compliance calendar with every filing deadline marked, including the quarters where you expect to report zero.

State registration deadlines start before you are ready

In Pennsylvania, new employers must register within 30 days after services covered by the Unemployment Compensation (UC) Law are first performed.

Increase for UC Delinquency, added to the assigned tax rate after a late registration
3%
Penalty per assessment for failing to register within 30 days
Up to $10,000

Start every registration the day you decide to hire. Not the day the employee starts. Not after the first paycheck. The day you make the decision.

Workers comp rules depend on the state

Workers compensation insurance rules are set state by state.

Workers' compensation insurance for private employers in two states
StateCoverage rule
CaliforniaRequired by law, even for an employer with only one employee
TexasPrivate employers can choose to carry it, and it is not required in most cases

Payroll providers that publish their prices

Gusto, OnPay and Patriot Software each publish a full-service payroll price.

Published payroll prices, as listed in September 2026
PlanBase per monthPer person, per monthPayroll tax filings
Gusto Simple$49$6 per personTax filings and payments, for payroll in one state
OnPay Payroll Essentials$49$6 per workerFederal, state and local taxes, with payroll in multiple states
Patriot Software Full Service Payroll$37$5 per worker paidFederal, state and local tax filings and deposits
Patriot Software Basic Payroll$17$4 per worker paidNot included

At the Gusto Simple list price, a business with three employees pays $804 a year.

OnPay lists one base plan, Payroll Essentials, with unlimited pay runs. Workers’ comp appears among its listed features.

Patriot Software Full Service Payroll comes to $624 a year for a business with three employees, at its list price.

For the providers named on this site, see which payroll providers publish their prices. Compare providers and features in our payroll provider reviews, pricing, and comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

When do I need to start running payroll for my new business?

Federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare withholding apply from the first paycheck. In Pennsylvania, new employers must register within 30 days after covered services are first performed.

How much does payroll cost for a small new business?

Full-service payroll for a new business with one to five employees costs $42 to $79 per month with Gusto, OnPay or Patriot Software, as listed in September 2026. That is $504 to $948 a year. Each of those full-service prices includes tax filings.

What are first-time employer payroll taxes I need to know about?

Beyond the standard federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare withholding from each paycheck, new employers owe the employer match for Social Security and Medicare. They also owe federal unemployment tax on the first $7,000 per employee in 2026 and state unemployment tax at the assigned new employer rate. Your state may also require disability insurance or paid family leave contributions.

What is the penalty for not having payroll set up?

At the federal level, the IRS failure to deposit penalty is 2% to 10% of the unpaid deposit, depending on how many days late it is. It rises to 15% for tax still unpaid more than 10 days after the first IRS notice. The failure to file penalty on a late Form 941 is 5% of the unpaid tax due with the return for each month or part of a month. The maximum is generally 25%. In Pennsylvania, late UC registration adds 3% to the assigned tax rate and can bring a penalty of up to $10,000 per assessment.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.