Last updated: November 2026

Nonprofit Payroll: Tax Obligations, FUTA Exemptions and Providers

Nonprofits owe payroll taxes.

In 2026, a nonprofit with ten employees paying $500,000 in annual wages owes approximately $38,250 in employer-side Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) tax alone. None of that is waived by the tax-exempt letter from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

Payroll taxes for a section 501(c)(3) organization
TaxWhat the organization does
Federal income taxWithholds it from employee pay, though the organization owes no federal income tax itself
Social Security and Medicare (FICA)Pays 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare and withholds the same from employee pay. Exceptions: an employee paid less than $100 in a calendar year, and the church election below
Federal unemployment tax (FUTA)Exempt under section 501(c)(3)
State unemployment tax (SUTA)Pays contributions like other employers, or elects to be a reimbursing employer instead

Where nonprofit payroll actually differs

Two areas separate nonprofit payroll from standard small business payroll. The first is federal unemployment tax. In 2026, the FUTA exemption saves roughly $42 per employee per year, the 0.6% rate after the maximum credit on the first $7,000 in wages.

On the state side, a reimbursing employer skips state unemployment tax contributions and instead reimburses the state dollar for dollar when a former employee collects unemployment benefits.

For nonprofits with low turnover, reimbursement can save money. For nonprofits with grant-funded positions that end when funding runs out, reimbursement can be devastating.

The second area is churches. Churches and church-controlled organizations opposed for religious reasons to paying Social Security and Medicare taxes can elect exemption by filing Form 8274. This shifts the Social Security and Medicare tax burden entirely to the employee, who pays self-employment tax instead if paid $108.28 or more in a year.

Employees Treated as Contractors

A program coordinator who works 30 hours per week on a set schedule, uses the nonprofit's equipment, and reports to the executive director is an employee under IRS rules. The contract's label does not change that. Misclassification exposes the nonprofit to back employment taxes.

That is not true when the worker genuinely operates an independent business. A freelance grant writer who serves multiple clients, sets their own hours, and uses their own tools is generally a legitimate 1099 contractor.

What your nonprofit payroll provider needs to handle

The FUTA exemption is the minimum requirement. If a payroll provider cannot flag your organization as FUTA-exempt and suppress those tax calculations, find a different provider. Beyond that, your nonprofit needs quarterly Form 941 filing, W-2 generation at year end, and state withholding and SUTA deposits or reimbursement tracking.

Payroll Providers for Nonprofits

Published payroll prices for a 10-employee nonprofit
ProviderPlan and rateCost per year at 10 employees
GustoSimple: $49 per month plus $6 per person$1,308
Patriot SoftwareFull Service Payroll: $37 per month plus $5 per worker paid$1,044

Gusto and Patriot as listed in September 2026.

Gusto. Gusto files 941s and state returns. QuickBooks, Xero, and Sage Intacct all integrate with Gusto.

Patriot Software. Patriot handles FUTA exemption and state filings.

ADP. ADP Workforce Now is sold by quote. A quote can include a price guarantee for a set number of years with increases built in, which is separate from the notice needed to cancel. Before signing, ask in writing for the guarantee period, any scheduled increases and the cancellation notice period.

How to set up nonprofit payroll

If you are switching from a different provider mid-year, your new provider will need year-to-date wage and tax data for every employee to generate accurate W-2s at year end. Compare providers to find the right fit, and do not let another pay period go by with taxes calculated incorrectly.

Frequently asked questions

Do nonprofits have to pay payroll taxes?

Yes. Nonprofits must withhold federal income tax, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax from employee wages and pay the employer share of FICA. 501(c)(3) organizations are exempt from FUTA, saving roughly $42 per employee per year in 2026.

Are churches exempt from FICA?

Churches and church-controlled organizations opposed for religious reasons to paying Social Security and Medicare taxes can elect exemption by filing IRS Form 8274. This shifts the entire Social Security and Medicare tax burden to the employee as self-employment tax, owed when the employee is paid $108.28 or more in a year.

Should my nonprofit be a reimbursing employer for unemployment?

It depends on your turnover rate. Reimbursing employers pay the state dollar for dollar when former employees collect unemployment, instead of paying SUTA contributions. Low-turnover nonprofits can save money with reimbursement. Nonprofits with grant-funded positions that end frequently may face large, unpredictable reimbursement bills.

This is not legal or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.